When switching, start the new policy first and cancel the old one effective the same day, with no gap. Stopping autopay is not a cancellation; you must formally cancel and confirm the effective date. Mid-term cancellations are usually refunded pro rata.
New first, then cancel
Cancel the old policy effective the day the new one starts.
Cancel formally
Stopping payment is not cancelling; request it in writing and confirm the date.
Pro-rata refund
Unused premium is usually refunded; some insurers charge a fee.
Read the full explanationHide the full explanation
Why a gap matters
Even a one-day lapse can mark you as having a coverage gap, raising future premiums. Lenders may also send notices or force-place expensive coverage.
Common situations
Switching insurers
Match the old policy's cancellation to the new start date; you may need to sign a cancellation request.
Selling a home
Cancel effective the closing date for a pro-rata refund and notify the lender if there is one.
Total loss
Don't cancel yet. Replacing the car on your existing policy is usually safer than buying new after a claim.
Moving
Don't cancel, update the address; renters can get a new certificate for the new landlord.
Lower income
California's Low Cost Auto Insurance Program is available to eligible drivers; compare before deciding.
What not to do
- Don't just stop autopay. The insurer will cancel for non-payment, which goes on your record.
- Don't cancel before the new policy starts.
- Don't rush to cancel after a claim. Ask first; adjusting your existing policy is often better.
A real case: totaled car, policy kept
A client's car was totaled and the title had gone to the insurer; he wanted to cancel the rest of his policy. We advised against it, since cancelling right after a claim can make a new policy hard to get. When he chose a new car, he sent the VIN and we replaced the vehicle on his existing policy.
Results depend on individual circumstances. Identifying details removed.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a cancellation fee?
Most refunds are pro rata; some policies use short-rate or charge a fee. Ask before cancelling.
My old policy wasn't through you. Can you cancel it?
We can help arrange it; usually you sign a cancellation request or confirm the date with the old insurer.
When will I get my refund?
Usually within a few weeks of processing; contact the old insurer if it does not arrive.
This article is general information for California and is not a promise of coverage or claim payment. Coverage, pricing and terms depend on each insurer's policy and underwriting.